Skip to main contentSkip to solution

In how many ways can 88 identical pens be distributed among Amal, Bimal, and Kamal so that Amal gets at least 11 pen, Bimal gets at least 22 pens, and Kamal gets at least 33 pens?

Entered answer:

Solution

✅ Correct Answer: 6

We need to distribute 8 identical pens among three people with specific minimum requirements:

Amal: at least 1 pen

Bimal: at least 2 pens

Kamal: at least 3 pens

The key insight is to satisfy the minimum requirements first, then distribute the remaining pens freely.


Let's give each person exactly what they need at minimum:

PersonMinimum RequiredPens Given
Amal11
Bimal22
Kamal33
Total66

Remaining pens = 8 - 6 = 2 pens


Now we need to find how many ways we can distribute 2 identical pens among 3 people with no restrictions.

If we give:

x1x_1 additional pens to Amal

x2x_2 additional pens to Bimal

x3x_3 additional pens to Kamal

Then: x1+x2+x3=2x_1 + x_2 + x_3 = 2 (where each xi≥0x_i \geq 0)


Let's list all possible ways to write 2 as a sum of three non-negative integers:

x1x_1x2x_2x3x_3Distribution Pattern
200(2,0,0)
110(1,1,0)
101(1,0,1)
020(0,2,0)
011(0,1,1)
002(0,0,2)

Total ways = 6


For advanced students: The number of ways to distribute n identical objects among k people is given by the combination formula:

n+k−1Ck−1{{}}^{n + k - 1}C_{k - 1} or n+k−1Cn{{}}^{n + k - 1}C_n

For our remaining 2 pens among 3 people:

2+3−1C2=4C2=4!2!×2!=6{{}}^{2 + 3 - 1}C_2 = {{}}^4C_2 = \frac{4!}{2! \times 2!} = 6

This confirms our answer!


The "minimum requirements first" approach is a powerful problem-solving strategy:

Satisfy all constraints

Distribute remaining items freely

Count using systematic enumeration or combinations

Answer: 6 ways

Keyboard Shortcuts

  • Left arrow: Previous question
  • Right arrow: Next question
  • S key: Jump to solution
  • Q key: Jump to question