Skip to main contentSkip to solution

The passage given below is followed by four alternate summaries. Choose the option that best captures the essence of the passage.

Brown et al. (2001) suggest that 'metabolic theory may provide a conceptual foundation for much of ecology just as genetic theory provides a foundation for much of evolutionary biology'. One of the successes of genetic theory is the diversity of theoretical approaches and models that have been developed and applied. A Web of Science (v. 5.9. Thomson Reuters) search on genetic* + theor* + evol* identifies more than 12000 publications between 2005 and 2012. Considering only the 10 most-cited papers within this 12000 publication set, genetic theory can be seen to focus on genome dynamics, phylogenetic inference, game theory and the regulation of gene expression. There is no one fundamental genetic equation, but rather a wide array of genetic models, ranging from simple to complex, with differing inputs and outputs, and divergent areas of application, loosely connected to each other through the shared conceptual foundation of heritable variation.

Solution

✅ Correct Option: 3

We need to find what it's really saying about both genetic theory and metabolic theory.

From passage: "Brown et al. (2001) suggest that 'metabolic theory may provide a conceptual foundation for much of ecology just as genetic theory provides a foundation for much of evolutionary biology'"

The passage structure: Shows genetic theory's success with diversity -> suggests metabolic theory might do similar for ecology.

Think process: Genetic theory works because it has many approaches -> Maybe metabolic theory can work the same way for ecology -> This is a suggestion, not a certainty.


🔴 Option 1 -> degree-error -> Says metabolic theory "must have the same" but passage only says it "may provide" - too strong and definitive

🔴 Option 2 -> contradicts main point -> Says metabolic theory "need not evolve in similar manner" but the whole passage suggests it could/should

🟠 Option 4 -> partial-truth -> Only talks about genetic theory as example but completely ignores the metabolic theory part, which is the main point

🟢 Option 3 is correct -> Captures both parts: genetic theory's success and metabolic theory's potential (not certainty) to do same for ecology


Key insight: The passage makes a comparison - genetic theory succeeded with diversity, so metabolic theory has potential to succeed similarly. Option 3 is the only one that captures both sides of this comparison with the right degree of certainty.

Keyboard Shortcuts

  • Left arrow: Previous question
  • Right arrow: Next question
  • S key: Jump to solution
  • Q key: Jump to question