Solution
Step 1: Understand what the study found
The key discovery -> penguins keep their outer feathers colder than the air around them, so they can actually steal tiny bits of heat from the air through convection.
From passage: "Since their outer plumage is even colder than the air, the simulation showed that they might gain back a little of this heat through thermal convection"
Step 2: Find the critical numbers
Air temperature -> 0.32°F
Plumage temperatures -> heads (-1.84°F), chests (-7.24°F), backs (-9.76°F)
Feet temperature -> 1.76°F
The magic happens because: plumage < air temperature, so heat flows from air to plumage
Elimination Strategy:
Look for the option that keeps the basic relationship intact -> plumage stays colder than air for convection to work
🔴 Option 2 -> scope-error -> says NO heat transfer can happen at all. But the entire study is about heat transfer through radiation and convection. This kills the whole study.
🔴 Option 3 -> reverses the key finding -> makes plumage temperatures positive (+1.84, +7.24, +9.76°F), all warmer than air (0.32°F). Now heat flows from plumage to air, opposite of what study found.
🔴 Option 4 -> reverses the relationship -> air becomes -10°F, much colder than plumage. Heat flows from plumage to air, destroying the convection advantage.
🟢 Option 1 -> minor detail change -> changes feet temp from 1.76°F to 2.76°F. Both temperatures are still warmer than air (0.32°F), so radiation still works the same way. The key plumage-colder-than-air relationship stays intact.
Option 1 doesn't break anything important -> the study's main findings survive perfectly.
More from this set:
Question 8