Skip to main contentSkip to solution

Scientists recently discovered that Emperor Penguins one of Antarctica's most celebrated species employ a particularly unusual technique for surviving the daily chill. As detailed in an article published today in the journal Biology Letters, the birds minimize heat loss by keeping the outer surface of their plumage below the temperature of the surrounding air. At the same time, the penguins' thick plumage insulates their body and keeps it toasty.

The researchers analyzed thermographic images taken over roughly a month during June 2008. During that period, the average air temperature was 0.320.32 degrees Fahrenheit. At the same time, the majority of the plumage covering the penguins' bodies was even colder: the surface of their warmest body part, their feet, was an average 1.761.76 degrees Fahrenheit, but the plumage on their heads, chests and backs were −1.84,−7.24-1.84,-7.24 and −9.76-9.76 degrees Fahrenheit respectively. Overall, nearly the entire outer surface of the penguins' bodies was below freezing at all times, except for their eyes and beaks. The scientists also used a computer simulation to determine how much heat was lost or gained from each part of the body-and discovered that by keeping their outer surface below air temperature, the birds might paradoxically be able to draw very slight amounts of heat from the air around them. The key to their trick is the difference between two different types of heat transfer: radiation and convection.

The penguins do lose internal body heat to the surrounding air through thermal radiation, just as our bodies do on a cold day. Because their bodies (but not surface plumage) are warmer than the surrounding air, heat gradually radiates outward over time, moving from a warmer material to a colder one. To maintain body temperature while losing heat, penguins, like all warm blooded animals, rely on the metabolism of food. The penguins, though, have an additional strategy. Since their outer plumage is even colder than the air, the simulation showed that they might gain back a little of this heat through thermal convection the transfer of heat via the movement of a fluid (in this case, the air). As the cold Antarctic air cycles around their bodies, slightly warmer air comes into contact with the plumage and donates minute amounts of heat back to the penguins, then cycles away at a slightly colder temperature.

Most of this heat, the researchers note, probably doesn't make it all the way through the plumage and back to the penguins' bodies, but it could make a slight difference. At the very least, the method by which a penguin's plumage wicks heat from the bitterly cold air that surrounds it helps to cancel out some of the heat that's radiating from its interior. And given the Emperors' unusually demanding breeding cycle, every bit of warmth counts. Since penguins trek as far as 7575 miles to the coast to breed and male penguins don't eat anything during the incubation period of 6464 days, conserving calories by giving up as little heat as possible is absolutely crucial.

All of the following, if true, would negate the findings of the study reported in the passage EXCEPT:

Solution

✅ Correct Option: 1

Step 1: Understand what the study found

The key discovery -> penguins keep their outer feathers colder than the air around them, so they can actually steal tiny bits of heat from the air through convection.

From passage: "Since their outer plumage is even colder than the air, the simulation showed that they might gain back a little of this heat through thermal convection"

Step 2: Find the critical numbers

Air temperature -> 0.32°F

Plumage temperatures -> heads (-1.84°F), chests (-7.24°F), backs (-9.76°F)

Feet temperature -> 1.76°F

The magic happens because: plumage < air temperature, so heat flows from air to plumage


Elimination Strategy:

Look for the option that keeps the basic relationship intact -> plumage stays colder than air for convection to work

🔴 Option 2 -> scope-error -> says NO heat transfer can happen at all. But the entire study is about heat transfer through radiation and convection. This kills the whole study.

🔴 Option 3 -> reverses the key finding -> makes plumage temperatures positive (+1.84, +7.24, +9.76°F), all warmer than air (0.32°F). Now heat flows from plumage to air, opposite of what study found.

🔴 Option 4 -> reverses the relationship -> air becomes -10°F, much colder than plumage. Heat flows from plumage to air, destroying the convection advantage.

🟢 Option 1 -> minor detail change -> changes feet temp from 1.76°F to 2.76°F. Both temperatures are still warmer than air (0.32°F), so radiation still works the same way. The key plumage-colder-than-air relationship stays intact.

Option 1 doesn't break anything important -> the study's main findings survive perfectly.

Keyboard Shortcuts

  • Left arrow: Previous question
  • Right arrow: Next question
  • S key: Jump to solution
  • Q key: Jump to question